About Us

Monteith's Best-One Tire & Auto Care serves the automotive repair, tire, and wheel needs of customers throughout Elkhart County, IN and the surrounding areas. Over the years we have expanded into 9 locations in Goshen, Elkhart, Middlebury, Warsaw, and Syracuse, IN.

The History of Monteith's Best-One Tire & Auto Care

Founded in 1966, Monteith's Best-One Tire & Auto Care has spent over 50 years delivering extensive auto repairs to satisfied customers throughout Elkhart County, IN and the surrounding areas. We focus on building strong customer relationships and providing the highest quality of workmanship on each and every automotive repair.

Kim Coleman went to work for Ray Monteith at Monteith Tire in Warsaw, IN, in 1968. Kim learned to serve the community from Ray’s leadership. Kim took those traits and opened Monteith Tire of Goshen on Greene Rd. in 1983 by purchasing the assets of Chrispyn Oil and Tire.

Kim’s vision of becoming Elkhart County’s finest tire and auto service center, along with his philosophy of building relationships with people by serving their tire and auto needs, has expanded Monteith Tire.

The first expansion under Kim’s management was in 1986 with the opening of Michiana Tire of Goshen. More locations were added in 1988, then Wakarusa in 1998, Goshen South in 1999 and Middlebury in 2008. Six locations in Elkhart County have more than 60 services bays.

Monteith's Best-One Tire & Auto Care is also a founding member of the Best One Tire and Service group with more than 250 locations throughout the Midwest. All of our services are backed by the Best One National pledge 12-month, 12,000-mile nationwide warranty. Plus, any NAPA parts are covered by the NAPA Auto Care Peace of Mind 12-month, 12,000-mile nationwide warranty. Monteith's Best-One Tire & Auto Care has your car service needs covered.

At Monteith's Best-One Tire & Auto Care, you can expect:

  • Quality repair services including brake repairs, wheel alignments, steering and suspension system repairs, transmission repairs, diagnostics, and exhaust system repairs from a TIA-certified tire dealership, performed by ASE-certified technicians
  • Competitive prices on tire brands like Bridgestone, Firestone, and Mastercraft
  • Passenger tires, commercial tires, ag tires, industrial tires, fork lift tires, farm tires, and OTR tires
  • Tire services including computer spin balancing, PAX tires, flat tire repairs, and tire rotations
  • Other services including state inspections, mobile repairs, lube and oil changes and other preventive maintenance, replacement of belts and hoses, and TPMS adjustments
  • Free Wi-Fi and free coffee in our waiting area
  • Financing

Browse Our Tire Catalog Browse Our Service Catalog

No matter where you live in Elkhart County, IN and the surrounding areas, Monteith's Best-One Tire & Auto Care should be your one-stop shop when considering auto repairs or new tires. Come into any Monteith's Best-One Tire & Auto Care location for a quote on an automotive repair service, or simply schedule your next service appointment online today.

Contact Us


Send »